REGIONAL #95:  This group had no pennant winners but lots of variety:  a standard deviation of 42 years around a mean season of 1964!   In thinking about contenders, I knew the Mets would win a pennant the following year, I suspected (as I incorrectly had in the last regional) that the Tigers were pretty good, and Giants teams from the 1970's had already captured three regionals and tend to play over their heads.  I picked the Mets over a steroid-era Padres team in the finals.  The ELO rankings instead picked the 1911 Cubs to beat the Mets, which I figured must involve some remnants of the Tinker to Evers to Chance group; however, I was comfortable with my choice as I doubted that a deadball era team would stand much of a chance against a similarly-ranked steroid-era squad.

 First round action  

My main recollection of the 96-loss 1971 Senators was that they had Frank Howard, one of my favorites from that era, but aside from a pretty good bullpen they had little else. I was thinking that the 1911 Cubs (92-62, 2nd place in the NL) had never seen the likes of Howard's 26 HR before, but Cubs RF Wildfire Schulte hit 21 HR himself--and he also hit 21 triples, almost as many as Hondo hit in his entire career! The Senators meager offense isn't helped when DH Jeff Burroughs is lost to injury for the tournament in the 3rd inning. The Cubs take a 1-0 lead in the 4th when Schulte doubles and Heinie Zimmerman singles him in, but the Nats tie it immediately in the top of the 5th when Howard doubles in Don Mincher on a missed HR split. In the 6th, Washington reels off four hits against Three Finger Brown, including a Tim Cullen triple, and suddenly the Senators hold a 4-1 lead and Cubs manager Frank Chance inserts himself into the lineup to try to provide a spark. In the 7th, Brown loads the bases on a hit and two walks, and the Cubs have to pull their HOFer in favor of Charlie Smith, who holds the Senators to 1 run on a Toby Harrah sac fly, but it's now 5-1 and Nats starter Pete Broberg is looking more like Pete Alexander. Two straight hits against Smith in the 8th, followed by a Hondo 3-run HR, and it's 8-1 Washington and Cubs fans are starting to blame a goat that won't even be born until 30 years later. And so it ends, with Broberg tossing a 3-hitter and Washington raking Cubs pitching for 17 hits, and the ELO regional favorite is blown out of the tournament in the 1st round.

The 76-win 1997 Padres against the 82-71 1927 Tigers posed an interesting matchup between a mediocre steroid era team and a decent team from the classic era.  After setting the lineup the Tigers looked like a much better team than the 1941 squad that won the previous regional, led by Harry Heilmann's gaudy .398 batting average, although the Padres' Tony Gwynn and his .372 average wasn't far behind.  The Tigers show Padre starter Joey Hamilton their hitting prowess early, batting around in the 2nd inning to score 5 runs with Neun and Gehringer both contributing 2-RBI singles.  The Padres respond with a run in the 3rd when Caminiti singles home Gwynn, but when the Tigers open the bottom of the 3rd with three straight hits, San Diego feels it has to go to closer Trevor Hoffman if they are going to have a chance in this game, so Hamilton departs after allowing 9 hits in 2 innings.  Hoffman promptly allows a hit, and the Tigers now lead 8-1 after three.  The Tigers score again in the 4th on a Taverner fielders choice, and meanwhile Tigers starter Earl Whitehill is cruising.  Fothergill drives in another Tiger run in the 8th against the third Padre pitcher, Bruske, and that puts the cap on the 10-1 Tiger victory and a convincing win for the classic era, although for a steroid-era squad the Padres were not a particularly power-laden example.

My choice for regional favorite, the 1999 Mets won 97 games and made the NLCS with lots of weapons--power, average, speed, defense, and a lockdown closer in Armando Benitez.  They faced a good 89-win 1978 Giants team who had a strong Bob Knepper on the mound, but on cardstock the Mets still looked like the better team by a comfortable margin.   However, the 1st inning had a lot of uncomfortable omens for the Mets--first, leadoff batter Terry Whitfield belts a HR, followed by an error from Mets 2B-1 Edgardo Alfonso; then when the Mets get their shot in the bottom of the 1st, leadoff hitter Roger Cedeno gets a single but is nailed by Marc Hill stealing 2nd despite Cedeno's AA rating.  Leading 1-0, the Giants then load the bases in the 4th with nobody out, but Al Leiter pitches his way out of the jam and keeps any runs from scoring.  The Mets finally get a run to tie the game in the bottom of the 7th when Piazza leads off the inning with a towering blast into the deepest reaches of Shea Stadium, but in the top of the 8th Darrell Evans leads off with a walk followed by a Jack Clark 2-run shot, and the Mets have to go to Benitez to try to keep things from getting worse.  He does his job, but the Mets offense is helpless against Knepper; they finally get a hit and a walk in the bottom of the 9th, putting John Olerud up as the potential game-winning run with one out, but Olerud hits into a double play, and the Mets go down quietly 3-1, while the Giants move on to the semis.

The 2017 Phillies lost 96 games and were a bad modern era team, but they still had 8 players in their lineup with a SLG% above .400, whereas the deadball 1911 Cardinals managed to go 75-74 with only two such sluggers.  The Phillies also had one decent starting pitcher, Aaron Nola, and the lone sub-.400 SLG% hitter in the Philadephia lineup--SS Freddie Galvis--staked Nola to a 1-0 lead on an RBI single in the 3rd.  The Cards tie it in the 4th, and then move to a 3-1 lead in the 5th courtesy of an Ed Konechty double.  St. Louis starter Slim Sallee is in control until the 7th, when Cameron Rupp hit a 2-out solo shot to narrow the lead to 3-2 Cards, but Mowrey's RBI single in the bottom of the 7th makes it 4-2 and then Miller Huggins finds Nola's HR result in the 8th to push the lead to the final margin of 6-2 Cardinals--the first of three 1911 teams in the past two regionals to survive the first round.

The survivors

Both the 1971 Senators and the 1927 Tigers won blowout games in the 1st round, with the Senators win being the bigger surprise.  Both teams had a significant dropoff in their #2 starters, with neither Dick Bosman nor Sam Gibson able to put together a winning record.  A two-out rally in the 2nd, culminating in a triple by DH Lu Blue, puts the Tigers up 2-0, and in the 3rd the Senators lose SS Toby Harrah to a 15-game injury--having already lost DH Jeff Burroughs for 10 games in the 1st round.  The Tigers put up two more in the 4th, and in the bottom of the 8th when Larry Woodall finds Bosman's HR result for a 3-run blast, the Senators summon Joe Grzenda and his 1.93 ERA, but that doesn't help and when the inning ends after 6 Tiger hits and 3 Senator errors, the score is 10-0 Detroit.   And that's how it ends, with Sam Gibson channeling Bob Gibson to record a 6-hit shutout, and the Tigers are on a roll seeking to capture a second straight regional for the franchise.

Bob Beats Blue

The 1978 Giants and the 1911 Cardinals both had their workhorses on the mound for their semifinal matchup, with Vida Blue (18-10, 258 IP) against Bob Harmon (23-16, 348 IP).  In the 2nd, the Cards lose LF Rube Ellis to a minor injury, and the lack of bench depth in these deadball era squads becomes glaringly apparent.  Even so, both workhorses are in fine form, and entering the 9th inning the game remains in a scoreless tie.  In the top of the 9th, Giants 1B Mike Ivie misses a HR split, and is stranded at second as Harmon records three straight outs.  For the Cards in the bottom of the 9th, Steve Evans leads off with a single, Blue whiffs Bresnahan, and Konechty hits a grounder to SS-3 Metzger, who can't complete the DP and Evans goes to 2nd as the potential winning run.  Blue delivers to Mike Mowrey--it's a 6-2 roll, and what should be there but a weird DO 1/SI** split; Evans scores and the Cards squeak into the finals with a 1-0 victory on Harmon's 5-hit shutout.

Not since Regional #43 had two pre-WWII teams faced off in a regional final, with both the 1927 Tigers and 1911 Cardinals disposing of more modern opponents in the first two rounds.  The Tigers had blasted their opposition to reach the finals, and they start off fast against the Cards, with Neun drawing a walk to lead off the top of the 1st, stealing second, and then Gehringer singles him home.  Three more straight hits and it's 3-0 Tigers before St. Louis has picked up a bat.  However, the Cards attempt to show that they aren't going down as quietly as had earlier Tiger opponents, with Miller Huggins leading off the bottom of the 1st with a HR off Tiger starter Ken Holloway's card.  Cards starter Bill Steele settles down, but in the 7th the Tigers load the bases with nobody out and convert for 2 runs on a Larry Woodall single, and they add 2 more in the 8th on RBIs from Heilmann and Fothergill to make it a 7-1 game.  Meanwhile, the Cards efforts are repeatedly stymied by the Tigers all-"1" DP combo, and Holloway ends with a 6-hit 7-1 victory and the Tigers win a second straight regional, outscoring the opposition by a 27-2 margin.

Interesting card of Regional #95:  Charlie Gehringer has always been one of my favorite players from the pre-WWII era, having served as a consistently productive member of various teams I've had in draft leagues I've played over the years.  I thought it was appropriate to select his card to be featured because the last two regional winners, the 1941 Tigers and the 1927 Tigers, had exactly one player in common:  Gehringer.  His 1941 card showed him as a shadow of his former self (although he still drew 95 walks), but the 1927 card pictured here reflects a 24 year just starting to show the abilities that would be on display for the next 15 years.  Although elected to the Hall of Fame, I've often thought that Gehringer has been somewhat overlooked among the greats of the game; for example, in 1929 he led the league in games played, plate appearances, runs scored, hits, doubles, triples, and stolen bases; he drove in 106 runs and had an OPS of .936--all that, and he didn't receive a SINGLE vote for MVP.  The baseball writers did finally award him the MVP in 1937, when he led the AL in batting with a .371 average.