SUPPLEMENTAL REGIONAL A3: Aside from the winners of two play-in games, the other six teams in this bracket were strong ones; two Series winners, a division winner, and a couple of other contenders. I figured that the top half of the group would see the champion ‘52 Yankees face off against their main competitor that season, the ‘52 Indians. On the bottom half I was thinking that the champion 1919 Reds would have a tough time keeping up with the power of the modern era, so I felt that the Astros would handle them, but fall to the Yankees in the final. The ELO ratings had no such reservations about the deadballers, tapping the Reds to handle the Yanks to take the regional and advance.
First round action
The 1952 Yankees went 95-59 to win the pennant and ultimately the Series, but the great teams of this storied franchise had suffered many first-round losses in this tournament and the Yanks were hoping that ace Allie Reynolds (20-8, 2.06) could ward off such an outcome. The 1952 Braves were in their final year in Boston, they had survived a play-in game behind Warren Spahn, but Max Surkont (12-13, 3.77) would be hard pressed to follow that up against a pennant winner. Nonetheless, Max looks strong, but so does Superchief and the game is locked in a scoreless tie after five innings. In the bottom of the 6th, Gene Woodling finally makes contact and knocks a solo homer into the short RF porch at Yankee Stadium, and that proves to be enough as Reynolds closes out a 6-hit shutout. Thus, the Yanks survive a scare but squeak past round one with a 1-0 victory to move on.
The 93-61 1952 Indians were the runners-up in the AL, in between two historic great pennant winners for the franchise, and Bob Lemon (22-11, 2.50) headed up the legendary pitching staff. They faced the modern era 2024 Red Sox, who finished at exactly .500 but hit 50 more homers as a team than the Tribe; the Sox would have Tanner Houck (9-10, 3.12) on the hill. Future Boston trade bait Rafael Devers singles home a run in the bottom of the 1st, and Tyler O’Neill adds a two-run homer in the 3rd to make it 3-0 Red Sox. Devers contributes a two-run shot of his own in the 5th, and the Indians sour on Lemon but the Red Sox continue to chip away at reliever Lou Brissie. The Indians get on the board with an RBI single by Dale Mitchell in the 8th, and Larry Doby hits a solo shot in the 9th as Houck tires but finishes out the easy 7-2 victory to pull off the upset and Boston advances to round two
The 2024 A’s lost 93 games, but they won a play-in game that earned them a berth in the tournament proper, and now their reward was facing the 86-76 2024 Tigers, a wildcard team that made the ALCS before exiting the post-season. Brother Chuck decided to pilot the underdog A’s, and I was feeling sufficiently confident in the Tigers that I would preserve ace Tarik Skubal and go with a pretty good Jack Flaherty (7-5, 2.95), figuring that the team had a sufficiently strong bullpen to handle any mishaps. Furthermore, A’s starter Joey Estes (7-9, 5.01) was not frightening anyone in the Tigers’ lineup, and when Spencer Torkelson hit a two-run homer in the bottom of the 2nd to put Detroit up 2-1 I figured that the game was in the bag. However, Flaherty was rocked for four hits in the top of the 3rd, including a bases-loaded single by JJ Bleday that drove in two to give the A’s the lead. Miguel Andujar adds a solo shot in the top of the 7th, while A’s closer Mason Miller comes in to contribute three strong relief innings to earn the save and wrap up the 4-2 win as the underdog A’s win their second in a row and move on.
The 1919 Reds allegedly won the World Series, but that was against a team accused of cheating–so it was ironic that they would draw the 88-73 2024 Astros as a first-round opponent, another franchise with a record of questionable practices in the Series. A matchup between a Series winner and a division winner merited Friday Night Strat game of the week honors, so Eaglesfly tapped impressive Dutch Ruether (19-6, 1.82) for the deadball Reds while Tall Tactician would bang the trash can for Framber Valdez (15-7, 2.91) and the ‘stros. However, in the top of the 1st Valdez looks more like Eddie Cicotte as he mysteriously can’t get anyone out; the Reds rattle off four hits and three runs, including a 2-run triple by Greasy Neale. An RBI double from Morrie Rath in the 2nd makes it 4-0 Reds, and the deadball era isn’t looking as dead as it has tended to be in this tournament. However, a solo homer by Jeremy Pena in the bottom of the 2nd begins to get across the differences between these eras of baseball, and Jose Altuve adds a two-run single that narrows the lead to one. That erodes in the 3rd as Yordan Alvarez swats a homer to tie the game, Alex Bregman adds an RBI single in the 5th, and Kyle Tucker crushes a three-run shot in the 6th and Houston is not having any problem with Ruether. Just to drive the point home, the Astros add five runs in the 8th, including a bases-loaded double from Alvarez that brings his RBI total to five, and meanwhile Valdez coasts for a comfortable 14-4 victory that sends the Astros on and the Reds back to the Diamond Gems section of the card catalogs.
The 2024 A’s had somehow won two games to reach this point in the tournament, but most bad teams tended to have rather gruesome options at the back end of their rotation and Mitch Spence (8-10, 4.58) didn’t appear to be an exception. The division-winning 2024 Astros had just disposed of a Series champion and Ronel Blanco (13-6, 2.80) looked up to the task of handling the lowly A’s, especially when Jeremy Pena gets Houston on the board in the bottom of the 1st with his second solo homer in as many games. However, the A’s answer in the top of the 3rd with an unlikely solo shot from Tyler Nevin, and Shea Langeliers adds another in the 6th while JJ Bleday pokes a two-run homer in the 7th and the underdog A’s lead 4-1. An RBI single by Jon Singleton chases Spence in the 8th and Jose Altuve adds a run-scoring double in the bottom of the 9th, but Tyler Ferguson strands the tying run at second base to preserve the 4-3 win and send the A’s to the regional final as a Cinderella entry.


